Donate Bitcoin

Donate Paypal


PeakOil is You

PeakOil is You

Do we have the right of secession?

What's on your mind?
General interest discussions, not necessarily related to depletion.

Right to secede?

Give me liberty or give me death! (Yes)
12
No votes
Give 'em death! (No)
1
No votes
 
Total votes : 13

Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby jaws » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 01:44:28

I want to know what peakoilers think of this. Is there a natural human right to secede from an oppressive government and establish a new government for protection?
User avatar
jaws
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1228
Joined: Sun 24 Apr 2005, 03:00:00

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby seahorse » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 01:50:35

Isn't this what the Declaration of Independence says?
User avatar
seahorse
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 2275
Joined: Fri 15 Oct 2004, 03:00:00
Location: Arkansas

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby Free » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 01:52:43

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', '
')Kugelmugel is a micronation located in Vienna, Austria.

In 1984, the artist Edwin Lipburger built a ball-shaped house with a barbed-wire fence around it on a small plot in the Vienna Prater and declared its independence as the Republic of Kugelmugel (the name referring to the shape).

The only address within the proclaimed Republic is "2, Antifaschismusplatz" (2, Anti-Fascism Square, 2 refers to the 2nd district Leopoldstadt), and the founder is one of the 389 citizens. He refused to pay taxes to the Austrian government and began to print his own stamps, for which he received a prison sentence in court. Only a pardon by the Austrian President saved him from going to jail.

As Kugelmugel came to be quite well-known in the public, it also became a tourist attraction of Vienna.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kugelmugel

This is actually not correct, he spent 10 weeks in prison for this...

So jaws, there is no excuse to not walk the talk, and we will visit you in Gitmo!

Image
"Democracy means the opportunity to be everyone's slave."
Karl Kraus
User avatar
Free
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1280
Joined: Sun 28 Nov 2004, 04:00:00
Location: Europe

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby peaker_2005 » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 01:53:19

There's a couple of examples of it here in Australia. Basically, the law is that if the Government ignores the notice of secesssion for 9 years, the secession is considered legal.

A few people have hence successfully managed to secede. :lol:
User avatar
peaker_2005
Tar Sands
Tar Sands
 
Posts: 686
Joined: Fri 02 Sep 2005, 03:00:00

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby jaws » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 01:56:26

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('seahorse', 'I')sn't this what the Declaration of Independence says?
Yes but that was sort of abolished by Lincoln.

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Free', '
')So jaws, there is no excuse to not walk the talk, and we will visit you in Gitmo!

Well that's the point. If you have a legitimate right to secede, they don't have the right to throw you in jail for it.
User avatar
jaws
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1228
Joined: Sun 24 Apr 2005, 03:00:00

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby Free » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 01:57:59

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('jaws', '
')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Free', '
')So jaws, there is no excuse to not walk the talk, and we will visit you in Gitmo!

Well that's the point. If you have a legitimate right to secede, they don't have the right to throw you in jail for it.


Well the solution is easy, just write your own law-book then and throw THEM in jail. Hm, I guess it's a stalemate then, who will decide who's right is superior? If only there was some kind of judge...oh wait, how about war? What was that Mao quote again, something that the law comes out of the barrel of a gun?
"Democracy means the opportunity to be everyone's slave."
Karl Kraus
User avatar
Free
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1280
Joined: Sun 28 Nov 2004, 04:00:00
Location: Europe
Top

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby Daculling » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 10:01:16

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Free', 'W')hat was that Mao quote again, something that the law comes out of the barrel of a gun?


The legality of secession is irrelevant. You are rejecting the original union. Expect to fight a war.... unless of course the original government thinks they are better off without you.
Daculling
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1228
Joined: Tue 12 Apr 2005, 03:00:00
Top

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby Trab » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 17:32:44

I believe the issue of whether states have the right to secede was settled between 1861 and 1865...
User avatar
Trab
Lignite
Lignite
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Thu 28 Oct 2004, 03:00:00
Location: SoWashCo, Minnesota

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby smallpoxgirl » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 18:18:45

I think there are two different questions there: Having a right is a moral/ethical issue. Having the ability to freely excercise a right is a political/military issue.

I would argue that you do in fact have a right to secession.

I doubt seriously that you have any ability to freely excercise that right.

So even though you have the right, it is currently being completely infringed by your government.
User avatar
smallpoxgirl
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 7258
Joined: Mon 08 Nov 2004, 04:00:00

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby k_semler » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 20:48:48

Yes you do. Just prepare for war. The CSA may have been ambivolent enough to let WV leave with no problems, but when the CSA wanted to seceede from the USA, the Civil War broke out. So yes you have the right. You better be prepared to fight for that right to the death though. Freedom is NOT free!!
Here Lies the United States Of America.

July 04, 1776 - June 23 2005

Epitaph: "The Experiment Is Over."

Rest In Peace.

Eminent Domain Was The Murderer.
k_semler
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1797
Joined: Mon 17 May 2004, 03:00:00
Location: Democratic People's Republic of Washington

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby jaws » Sat 04 Feb 2006, 22:24:19

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('smallpoxgirl', 'S')o even though you have the right, it is currently being completely infringed by your government.
So are all of our other rights, but they are still rights.
User avatar
jaws
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1228
Joined: Sun 24 Apr 2005, 03:00:00
Top

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby Keith_McClary » Sun 05 Feb 2006, 01:58:18

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('jaws', 'I') want to know what peakoilers think of this. Is there a natural human right to secede from an oppressive government and establish a new government for protection?


Puffin Island
[web]http://www.guardian.co.uk/post/story/0,,1340472,00.html[/web]
User avatar
Keith_McClary
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 7344
Joined: Wed 21 Jul 2004, 03:00:00
Location: Suburban tar sands
Top

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby Specop_007 » Sun 05 Feb 2006, 02:32:16

Why seccede? Just overthrow the governmnet.
Question of the night. When was the last time American people had an armed revolution to overthrew the governmnet (local, state or federal)?

The answer might suprise you......





Click


Revolt in Athens, Tennessee!
20 People Wounded
14 Autos Overturned, and Burned at Town Square
Jail Under Seize 8 hours
Sheriff, Senator & Others Flee County

Athens, Tennessee: The uprising was led by ex-GIs recently returned from battle, to discover dishonest election tactics and corrupt and crooked local government. Having seen first-hand, Tennessee blood spilled and Tennessee lives lost in the battle for freedom, these patriotic veterans weren't about to knuckle under to the special interests. Certain insiders, for their own profit and benefit, had taken control of the small community of Athens, a town of about 7600 people.

The violence started on election day when a poll watcher was attacked and thrown through a glass door. The town folks, already agitated, became incensed. They went home and returned with pistols, shotguns and whatever weapons they could lay their hands on. The incumbents and "insiders" had recruited extra deputies from neighboring cities and counties but they were no match for the now armed and angry citizens of McMinn County. Sheriff Pat Mansfield and State Senator Paul Cantrell, along with others, fled the scene. Twenty-five deputys retreated to the jail which was surrounded and fired upon by the civillian army.

At 4:00 A.M. the next morning, the "25" surrendered their arms and came out with hands up. Although a cry went up to "hang 'em", cooler heads prevailed. The "25" were taken to the edge of town, stripped naked and told not to come back.

The upshot was the incumbent and "insider-clique" were out. The slate backed by the citizens and supported by the GI patriots was officially certified victorious by State authorities in Nashville.

Thus, a new sheriff, trustee, register of deeds, circuit court clerk and county court clerk were seated (3 Democrats, 2 Republicans). All were new, all were honest and freely elected. The year was 1946. In 1948, a city council / county commission form of government, one of the first in the state of Tennessee was created. Athens prospered and grew and today has more than doubled in population.
"Battle not with monsters, lest ye become a monster, and if you gaze into the
Abyss, the Abyss gazes also into you."

Ammo at a gunfight is like bubblegum in grade school: If you havent brought enough for everyone, you're in trouble
User avatar
Specop_007
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 5586
Joined: Thu 12 Aug 2004, 03:00:00

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby smallpoxgirl » Sun 05 Feb 2006, 02:54:32

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Specop_007', 'Q')uestion of the night. When was the last time American people had an armed revolution to overthrew the governmnet (local, state or federal)?


Ummm....sorry Specop. BZZT! Thank you for playing.

There have been any number of armed uprisings since 1946: The Black Panthers, Weatherman, the SLA, three different Watts uprisings, dozens of inner city uprisings in the summer of 1969, Waco, the Montana freemen, it's a pretty long list. Many of them sought to overturn the government and had much longer lives and met with greater success than a few drunk Athens, TN, rednecks shooting up the town after their shift at the carpet factory.

The American people, however, have never had a succesfull armed revolution. The so called American revolution in point of fact fits much more closely with the definition of a coup. A revolution denotes a fundamental rethinking and realignment of the political and social structure of a nation. In the American "revolution" there was no such realignment. The power structures were virtually identical before and after. Most of the office holders weren't even changed, just one level of upper management peeled off.
User avatar
smallpoxgirl
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 7258
Joined: Mon 08 Nov 2004, 04:00:00
Top

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby Specop_007 » Sun 05 Feb 2006, 03:09:25

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('smallpoxgirl', '')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Specop_007', 'Q')uestion of the night. When was the last time American people had an armed revolution to overthrew the governmnet (local, state or federal)?


Ummm....sorry Specop. BZZT! Thank you for playing.

There have been any number of armed uprisings since 1946: The Black Panthers, Weatherman, the SLA, three different Watts uprisings, dozens of inner city uprisings in the summer of 1969, Waco, the Montana freemen, it's a pretty long list. Many of them sought to overturn the government and had much longer lives and met with greater success than a few drunk Athens, TN, rednecks shooting up the town after their shift at the carpet factory.

The American people, however, have never had a succesfull armed revolution. The so called American revolution in point of fact fits much more closely with the definition of a coup. A revolution denotes a fundamental rethinking and realignment of the political and social structure of a nation. In the American "revolution" there was no such realignment. The power structures were virtually identical before and after. Most of the office holders weren't even changed, just one level of upper management peeled off.

None of those uprisings you mentioned were successful. Thats the key difference. In the Athens incident the citizens took up arms against the existing local government and threw them out of town. It was a successful revolt. Nothing since has happened. There have been uprisings but they have accomplished nothing.
"Battle not with monsters, lest ye become a monster, and if you gaze into the
Abyss, the Abyss gazes also into you."

Ammo at a gunfight is like bubblegum in grade school: If you havent brought enough for everyone, you're in trouble
User avatar
Specop_007
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 5586
Joined: Thu 12 Aug 2004, 03:00:00
Top

Re: Do we have the right of secession?

Unread postby k_semler » Sun 05 Feb 2006, 03:10:00

@Specop_007:

I bring to you these incidents:

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Do you know the 10 most dangerous words in the English language? "I'm from the government, and I'm here to help you."
Last edited by k_semler on Sun 05 Feb 2006, 03:15:04, edited 1 time in total.
Here Lies the United States Of America.

July 04, 1776 - June 23 2005

Epitaph: "The Experiment Is Over."

Rest In Peace.

Eminent Domain Was The Murderer.
k_semler
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1797
Joined: Mon 17 May 2004, 03:00:00
Location: Democratic People's Republic of Washington


Return to Open Topic Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests