by trespam » Thu 19 Aug 2004, 04:16:25
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('larrydallas', 'W')ell, I don't think all luxury cars are a bad thing. If you have worked hard your whole life and now you are in your 70's you deserve to own a vehicle that is very comfortable and easy to drive. The whisper soft ride of the Lexus LS series is something I am not offended by. Despite having a 4300cc V8 it delivers around 20-24 mpg.
At each level of the socio-economic hierarchy, people argue that they can "afford" to live a certain lifestyle. E.g. the elite ride around the globe in private jets and then argue that it's ok because not everyone can do this. Move down a level, and we have the people riding first class on a weekend flight to do some shopping across the Atlantic. Down a little further, the guy riding around in his luxury car. Go all the way down the hierarchy. People are living above the standard of living that the earth will support without cheap oil. Except at a certain point down the hierarchy, at which point people are living a life, consuming resources, in a way that the earth can support long-term (without cheap energy).
So as much as we hate the SUV driver, they are only a symbol of our overall excess. The Lexus driver is a part of the problem. The Prius driver is part of the problem. The motorcycle driver is part of the problem. Because at some point, if everyone on the globe aspires to a motorcycle, we will eventually run into the same problem--no oil.
So some point to the people who are living at the bottom of the socio-economic ladder. The are the problem. They are aspiring to a life that the earth cannot afford. The complaint is commonly directed against the Chinese now. Funny, for years the US told them to aspire to capitalism, to aspire to materialism. Now there are probably a few who wouldn't rather see a turn back to a more agrarian society. Because in addition to cheap labor, which we love, the chinese are taking their earnings and purchasing motorcycles and automobiles.
So the Hummer owner, who is a symbol of our excess, is just that: a symbol. The lexus driver and the motorcycle driver perhaps carry a bit less blame, but not much. Our way of life is not sustainable, because it will eventually consume the fossil fuels and expel the carbon they hold into the atmosphere.