by steam_cannon » Sat 22 Mar 2008, 11:33:35
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('yeahbut', 'I') don't think you really took on board what I said was effective for
my friend. She didn't do loads of running and exercise all the time...
Right, a short burst of exercise raises GABA neurotransmitters and
on the distribution curve for severity of this illness I'm sure you can
expect this to be enough for some people to get by. However you
can also expect that many other people would need to do more
exercise then her or take other steps for treatment.
Do you get how stupid debating this is. Some diabetics can be
treated with diet alone. But many diabetics need insulin. You can't
generalize that dietary changes will work for all diabetics any more
then you can say exercise will work for all panic disorders.
Dietary changes alone don't help most diabetics and I doubt you
can expect exercise alone to help for even most panic disorders.
As I've said, it's something to try but it's not the only option and
I'm sure it's not the right option for all people, such as people
with dietary deficiencies.
It's the same for a person with mild anemia. An exercise program
will increase the oxygen carrying capacity of their blood, but only if
they get enough iron in their diet and if they have intestinal
parasites leaching blood, they will need even more iron and other
treatments. If they have a thyroid disorder causing the anemia,
exercise will help but it certainly isn't a solution to their root problem.
Exercise can help most things and is always recommended. But try
and think about underlying problems a little too.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('yeahbut', 'S')he just responded(with a short burst of whatever exercise or
movement she could manage depending on her circumstances) to
the 'fight or flight' adrenalin rushes she received
during a panic
attack. This gave a physical 'out' to the panic she was feeling,
and was highly effective in defusing the awful sensations. It was a
very simple strategy, it worked for her and saved her from what
was becoming a crippling condition.
crashing GABA neurotransmitters. Exercise kicks that up and the
adrenalin response encourages exercise. Unless your friend has an
adrenal disorder, the problem goes back to neurotransmitter issues.
Running around, moving a bit, flapping your arms... All of that raises
GABA neurotransmitters back to normal, the root problem.
flap my arms at random times of the day.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------