Good thread TB.
I don't know if you're familiar with Ken Wilber and his work, and it would be pretty much impossible for me to summarize it here, but I will say that I think it relates a lot to these ideas.
Ken's 'life work' so to speak, has been to formulate a comprehensive 'map' of the human experience that attempts to synthesize information from as many different disciplines and world views as possible, with a great deal of emphasis on the evolution of consciousness. His stuff is definitely
not light reading, but if one can manage to wrap their mind around it, his work gives one a
much broader understanding about humanity than any other author I've come across.
Anyway, regarding the issue of New Age, and particularly the point culicomorpha makes regarding the extreme emphasis on the individual. This isn't a phenomenon exclusive to New Agers; it's actually endemic in our culture as a whole, particularly among the Boomers (the so-called "Me Generation" recall), and it's not difficult to understand why if one considers that such hyper-individualism is precisely what the lords of capitalism require, and precisely what they've deliberately instilled over the last half-century or so through media and schooling. There's a great documentary titled
The Century of the Self that explores this particular topic in depth; I highly recommend it (it's in four parts, and for some odd reason part two never seems to show up in the "Related Videos" frame on Google video, but if you search the title plus the string "2 of 4" you'll find it).
Returning to Ken Wilber: there is a phenomenon related to the growth of consciousness that he refers to as the "Pre-Trans Fallacy"; consider that as humans mature from birth to adolescence to adulthood, they pass through a series of developmental stages, not only on a physical level but on psychological and emotional levels as well. Broadly speaking, the psychological stages can be divided into three general levels, labeled pre-rational, rational and post- (or
trans-) rational. The third is also sometimes referred to as trans-personal (as in Trans-personal Psychology). An alternate labeling is pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional.
The pre-rational stage occurs during childhood, and is very much ego-centric. Children of course see themselves pretty much as the center of the universe; their early thinking is based largely on a belief that they can manipulate the world simply through the force of their will. This is the level of so-called
magical thinking. Watch some Saturday morning cartoons and you will see that they are rife with this level of functioning - super heroes/villains that point and zap people, make things move with their minds, are basically immune to harm, etc. So-called 'power magic' is also drawn from this level, voodoo being one prominent example.
Eventually a child comes to realize that such power magic
doesn't work, and so magical thinking gives way to
mythic thinking, wherein now it's not
me who controls the world, it's
God(s)/Goddess(es) (initially Mom & Dad) who control it, and if I just find the right way to pray to/placate the Deity then
it will move the world
for me. This level is also referred to as
conventional or
ethno-centric, because it is from our 'tribal group' that we learn the
one right way to live, the
social conventions, that earn the Deity's favor. This is also, incidentally, the general level of development that a large percentage of humanity is currently at, and it is still
pre-rational.
A smaller percentage have matured to the rational level, where there is recognition that we are directly responsible for our actions
and their consequences, where we begin to question the dictates of our 'tribal' conventionality and develop our own moral compass, thus developing a
post-conventional,
world-centric perspective. This is the level of the "All men are created equal" of the U.S. Constitution.
Fewer still (estimates are around 1 - 3% of the population if I recall) have grown even further in psychological terms to a level where they not only identify themselves as individuals amongst equal individuals, but they recognize,
as an ongoing, living experience, the Oneness of humanity; their's is a truly
trans-personal identity, and there are understandings and modes of functioning that are unique to this level of Awareness.
This is where we get to the
Pre-Trans Fallacy, and particularly as it manifests among the New Age community. Both pre-rational and trans-rational levels are
non-rational, and as a result they are frequently confused. "I make/control the world" (ala 'The Secret') is a pre-rational,
ego-centric perspective that has been mis-taken to be a logical extension of the trans-rational Awareness that "I and the world are One". Variations on this fundamental misunderstanding are rampant, and it is this misunderstanding that is the root of the 'abdication of responsibility' that culicomorpha mentions. A genuinely trans-rational,
world-centric Awareness of Oneness recognizes that
because I am One with All, it is unthinkable that I would not care equally for the Totality of Myself.
"It means buckle your seatbelt, Dorothy, because Kansas? Is goin' bye-bye... "