by EnergyUnlimited » Wed 03 Oct 2007, 04:00:35
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Ibon', 'B')ut I see you still as defeatist. Where as I have dropped my opinions as to where humanity is heading can you say the same?
Uncharted waters best sums it up. To hold on to utopic beliefs in some cultural transformation coming up ahead is just as delusional as convincing yourself that we are inevitably heading toward wars etc.
It's nice to drop the baggage of having a belief that you try to twist reality around. Can you say the same?
My defeatist attitude is due to realization, that we do not have
time to introduce necessary changes to our consumerist behaviour, economic paradigm, religious beliefs etc.
It is not due to my inability to contemplate such changes in principle.
I can see a path to achieve such changes, as long as humanity got
at least 100 years to adapt it's values but 200-300 years is probably more adequate period of time.
On the other hand I am convinced that any "crush course" to achieve necessary changes would result in societal disasters, wars, revolutions, civil wars etc.
The results would be comparable to resource wars and usual course of die-off without any guarantee that meaningful changes could be implemented at all.
So if we started to push towards those changes in 1960-ties (sexual revolution was a good opportunity to start with...) we could now be on good path to success and at 2050 most of job could be done. Few peoples would feel unduly oppressed and majority of those who did so would not live long enough to face grossly different society.
Nevertheless wheel of fortune has turned the wrong way and now we are living in societies with wrong set of values and time is running out.
Even so, as we observe world around, there is no will to transform and all human intelligence and effort is directed towards continuation of
status quo.
20 years from now on at the latest we will see die-off unrolling, that will cause wars etc and humanity will deal with overshot in traditional way as directed by Nature.
Die-off time is not the best to try changes either. Peoples are known to stick to their values and beliefs in such circumstances.
So the keyword to my defeatism is one simple word -
time, or rather lack of it.
In any case I am only defeatist in respect to overall prospects of large global civilization.
I am quite optimistic in respect to success of many local communities (local, means not larger than medium size nation wide).
Many of those will certainly succeed, but some others will perish...