by rostov » Wed 27 Dec 2006, 11:47:22
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Loki', '
')First off, is it really worth going to Linux? Is it stable?
Stability used to be touted as Linux's strength in the "older days" (< 2003?) when compared with windows for all ranges of uses. Very hot topic/debate, and not worth going into.
In short, stability is not the issue.
Drivers is.
What's the model of your laptop?
This site could probably yield some information on running various linux distros on your hardware.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'A')lso, is it possible to have both Linux and Windows on the same computer?
Yes. Two methods available commonly.
1) Dual boot.
Personally, I'd avoid this.
2) Virtual machine in linux. Tradeoff a chunk of your CPU/memory/harddisk for running a parallel virtual host on your linux machine when needed.
(EDIT : There are 3. Sorry)
3) Application/Windows emulator.
http://www.winehq.com. Basically a bug-for-bug windows emulator for each application. There are commercially available ones (which are easier to use :
Crossover). I didn't initially think of this because its main limitation is supported applications like ArcGIS stuff. Other than that, it's a better tradeoff for resources because it doesn't need a guest OS to run and hence lesser cpu/ram/hdd footprint
(/EDIT)
http://www.vmware.com has a free downloadable version of vmware server 3.0 for both linux (you'd want this) and windows. Once up and running, decide resources necessary to sacrifice to a running windows program (swap space will be used heavily)
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'I')'d like to use my old laptop for this experiment---it only has a 20GB HD, 256MB RAM, and a very old and slow CPU (AMD 1400+). The only reason I'd keep Windows on this machine is so I can run ArcGIS, which requires Windows. Any links, advice, or other info folks here can offer would be most appreciated.
ArcGIS has several components. As of 9.01, the server products (ArcSDE, ArcIMS, ArcObjects) have versions for Linux and solaris, while there are no linux products for the desktop products (ArcMap, ArcCatalog, ArcInfo family). The development SDK runs on linux (I think). Without knowing much about your ArcGIS requirements, I'd assume you'd be running the server on your linux OS, and when needed, fire up vmware client for the client suites.
Note that you can make vmware chew up startup times for your desktop by auto-starting the windows guest virtual host. Only when you want to access the running windows os, run "vmware" within the windows manager and viola, you'd jump straight in. It'll happily sit in limited memory and mostly swap during the duration it's started while you use the Linux host OS for other stuff.
Your machine probably is pretty decent for basic desktop/linux (IMHO), but very edgy especially if used for GIS-related work. The AMD1400 is either a 133/266MHz FSB ... is there any way you could grab 1-2GB ram off ebay for max of a couple hundred bucks once your experiement proves to be a success? Or borrow some?
I'm back to my basic concern : drivers. If this is your first (few) times of running linux over the years, might I suggest the ubuntu branches, especially kubuntu? They're pretty nifty when it comes to driver detection, installation, and configuration of drivers. I find gnome (ubuntu) a little bit more lacking in user-experience compared to kde (kubuntu) when introducing it to a volunteer org here... (Warning : kde/gnome hot topic)
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'A')lso, are there any decent open source Word type programs? How about spreadsheet programs like Excel? I'm already running Firefox, which usually works OK when it isn't crashing. But it's still better than Explorer, which I've come to absolutely loath.
Firefox 2.0 for browsing pretty much wraps it. Unless you could try opera (free) a go ... 2 converted associates swear off firefox for it's simplicity and stability (my view varies).
Openoffice.org pretty much wraps it. You'll be living with quite a bit of useability differences compared to microsoft office -- might you download and try the windows version just before you make the plunge? Note that import/export filters for openoffice is getting better but not 100%, so interchangeability of docs (to-fro) between OO and MSO is going to be a pain at times.
Another alternative is to get that ram and throw microsoft office into vmware...