by Ibon » Mon 17 Oct 2005, 12:28:23
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('DigitalCubano', ' ')I think that many doomers shortchange the ability of the average person to change and the value of our accumulated knowledge base. I still think that we will have to "powerdown," especially with regards to transportation. As a result, things will be different, but not necessarily worse.
This is very true. Here is my morning rant. Many of the doomers, particularly those who have dedicated years or decades to the issues of environmental degradation and rallied for sustainability only found this falling on deaf ears as the status quo continued consuming away. It is very understandable that they have developed a view of the masses as intractable and incapable of shifting, almost as bound to their behavior as many animals are to their behavioral instincts. Doomers claim we are in overshoot and heading for an unavoidable collapse basing this on ecological case studies of animals and past human societies. Their certainty that we are heading the same way has been reinforced because for the past several decades as a result of cheap oil we have indeed acted exactly as the ecological model has predicted. We have overshot and we have brought ourselves to the brink of collapse and like some mindless goats on a small island we continue to eat away our future resources with a mindless abandon.
Here is the fallacy in the doomers certainty of collapse. They confuse the cause and effect of human behavior and cheap oil. It is not our intractable behavior as a species that has brought us to the brink but instead it is the abundant cheap oil that has allowed us to follow mindlessly a course that has lead us to an unsustainable world. Cheap oil built up our technology but made things so easy that it has turned into an addictive drug that has actually held back innovation in both technology and culture for the past decades as it removed the integrity inherent in survival and made us soft like slugs. It has kept us basically stupid I would say for the past 20-30 years. The current liquid fuel crisis in fossil fuels is the first serious bump in the road. If we just go back one year peak oil and energy issues weren't in the press and the pioneers who understood the severity of this issue were still talking about why this isn't headline news. Well here we are a year later and the cause and effect on more expensive energy has suddenly caused the mindless goats to wake up. We are witnessing the momentum growing toward a huge cultural shift. It hasn't yet really taken off but it is rapidly gaining momentum. We will wean ourselves from the addiction of cheap energy and our survival instincts that have seemed so long dormant will awaken out of necessity. It will actually increase our quality of life even though materially we may lose something as it will put meaning back into our existence. Roche should be concerned about dropping sales of Prozac once this crisis hits.
As regards to the neoconservative agenda heading us toward resource wars I don't see this happening. They are losing their appeal by the day and the interdependent global economy and geopolitics will check mate them just as the American public is now waking up to the lies and propaganda. They will be looked back on as an anomaly and another symptom of the cheap oil energy addiction. Neo conservatives are like babies in diapers having a tantrum because their ability to suck on the baby bottle of cheap oil is being taken away from them and they now have to share the sandbox with others. The fear of resource wars is as obsolete as nuclear wars. The emerging energy crisis reveals that there are no long term strategies to win this except a global cooperative effort. Radicals like neoconservatives will have no place at the table and they will not maintain their power base much longer. This is part of the cultural shift that you can see already playing out in Mr. George Bush's current popularity under 40%. This is an indictment of the whole administration he leads or who leads him like a puppet on a string.
We got some tough times ahead but they are incredibly exciting times as well. We are witnessing history in the making as we undergo an unprecedented cultural shift. The weaning of this cheap energy addiction and the hardships this will cause may will put dignity and meaning back into our human existence and therefore give us a greater quality of life even though we may lose many of the conveniences of modern living. This is anything but collapse.