by Outcast_Searcher » Sat 04 Sep 2010, 04:58:17
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Cid_Yama', 'U')S population as of 2009 is 310,152,000. The 11 million illegal imigrants include families so are not entirely workforce any more than the entire population of the US.
3.5% is still not enough to significantly affect wages. Which would only slightly affect the unskilled labor pool, and the skilled labor pool, not at all.
The argument is still nonsense.
I'm confused. I thought that businesses, especially agribusiness, wanted low skill illegals so they could employ them off the books. This lets them avoid things like the minimum wage, reguired taxes, insurance, etc. Surely that magnifies the downward pressure on wages for low skilled American citizens.
I suspect this is a far bigger issue than whether the proper percentage of low skilled illegal workers is (say) 2% or 4% of the labor force. I also suspect this is the REAL reason our wonderful politicians including Mr. Obama, do NOTHING about meaningful immigration reform to get everyone on the books -- besides make speeches with empty promises.
Besides, if the un/low skilled portion of the American workforce is, say, 25% of the entire workforce (even sales clerks read and use cash registers), then these illegals are perhaps 8% to 16% of the un/low skilled workers. If we don't try to (roughly) use valid comparisons here, we won't get meaningful percentages to consider the likely impact to wages.
I agree that for high skilled workers, the competition is a nonissue.
(Don't get me wrong. I don't care where folks come from or what they look like - but I want everyone who lives here to compete under the same rules and laws, pay taxes under the same laws, receive benefits under the same rules, etc. I also don't want greedy corporations to use illegals as a way to illegally get a below-market labor source for them to exploit. That's why I want to see a comprehensive immigration policy -- not to punish people or throw them out).
Given the track record of the perma-doomer blogs, I wouldn't bet a fast crash doomer's money on their predictions.