Syriana and Iraq

Critics have been hailing “Syriana,” George Clooney’s latest film to take on the policies of the Bush Administration, as a cinematic tour de force that has “compelling real-world relevance” and is “unsettlingly close to the truth.” But what is the truth “Syriana” supposedly approaches? Put briefly, the plot describes the ramification of a bungled CIA-authorized assassination of a Middle Eastern leader who decided to sign a major oil deal with China instead of an American oil company with close ties to the US Government.

Given the increasing numbers of Americans who believe that the Bush administration deliberately misled the country to justify the Iraqi invasion, many film-goers will no doubt walk accept the film’s argument that Big Oil shapes American policies to its interests, even when they violate our core ideals. But is the movie really a case of art imitating life, or does “Syriana” veer towards the kind of hyperbole and exaggeration that marred Oliver Stone’s “JFK?”
The evidence would seem to speak for itself. It includes:

– Newly discovered documents, reported in the Washington Post, that reveal that as early as February 2001 senior executives of at least four of the country’s biggest oil companies, ExxonMobil, Conoco, Shell and BP America, met with Vice President Cheney’s Energy Task Force.

– Documents from these meetings obtained by the conservative watchdog Judicial Watch–including a map of Iraq and an accompanying list of “Iraq oil foreign suitors”–reveal Iraq, with perhaps the world’s second largest oil deposits, to have been a major topic of discussion. Indeed, the map erased all features of the country save the location of its main oil deposits. The list of suitors revealed that dozens of foreign companies were either in discussions over or in direct negotiations for rights to some of the best remaining oilfields on earth.

– The meetings occurred at a moment when scientists and industry leaders began worrying that the “age of peak oil production” is approaching faster than previously assumed. Once it arrives, it will no longer be possible to extract enough oil from the earth to replace what we consume, thereby setting off a potentially explosive competition for the world’s remaining supplies.

History News Network