Page added on August 2, 2016
Crude oil prices dropped on Monday, dipping below the $40 a barrel mark for the first time since April. Weeks of slow decline precipitated this 4% loss, which many are blaming on poor earnings from ExxonMobil XOM +0.93% and Chevron CVX +0.13%. The truth is that for most of the summer oil has been overpriced. The global crude oil glut is not resolving and has been joined by a gasoline glut, which, to the delight of American consumers, is pushing gasoline prices down across the nation.
Why were we tricked into thinking the worst of the oil glut was over? Production disruptions in Nigeria, Canada, Libya and Venezuela took hundreds of thousands of barrels out of the market for weeks at a time this spring. In the old market of oil – say in 2013 – this would have raised concerns about shortages. In the 2016 market, however, these disruptions were easily covered by stored oil and production increases in Saudi Arabia, Iran, Russia and the United States. Now that the disruptions are over and the market is finally coming to terms with how much oil is still out there, we are seeing the price correction down.
Some additional factors weighing on the price of oil include the following:
Fracking: Shale oil companies in the United States that made it through the $30 oil period earlier this year are well financed to keep producing – even if oil remains below $50 a barrel. These companies have secure loans from banks and are employing more strategic methods to tap only the cheapest and easiest oil to drill. The number of rigs opened in the U.S. has grown for five straight weeks. Increasing oil production will keep prices from rising, and it probably will not drop prices quite enough to force these companies to stop production.
Speculation: Bets by hedge funds and other speculators helped magnify the price drop. Most fund managers believe the oil market will continue to drop, at least in the short term. So convinced are they, that news that ISIS bombed an Iraqi oilfield in Kirkuk yesterday did not even cause a noticeable blip in oil’s fall.
A picture taken with a mobile phone shows smoke billowing from oil silos following an attack by militants on a gas facility and the nearby Bai Hassan oil field in Iraq’s northern Kirkuk province on July 31, 2016.Gunmen travelling on motorbikes opened fire on the gas facility’s guards, then killed four of its employees and planted multiple bombs before escaping, officials from Iraq’s North Oil Company and the Kurdish peshmerga forces said. / AFP / STRINGER (Photo credit should read STRINGER/AFP/Getty Images)
Iran: Iranian oil exports climbed steadily through June. Iran also offered huge discounts to its customers. The Iranian effect contributed to the current drop in oil prices. It seems that Iran’s exports are now leveling off at just shy of four million barrels a day, so Iran may have reached its exporting limit. That would mean the Iranian effect would not drag oil prices much lower. However, Iran’s general untrustworthiness makes it difficult to know exactly what is going on with their oil industry.
Saudi Arabia: Saudi Arabia recently increased its oil production and cut the price of its oil exports to Asia. Usually, in the summer months Saudi Arabia and oil-producing Gulf neighbors divert huge amounts of their production to domestic uses to power air conditioners and other electric needs. Unlike most other countries, Saudi Arabia uses oil to produce much of its electricity. However, this year, despite the record heat, Saudi Arabia has increased production to keep pace with both domestic electricity use and growing exports to Asia.
Ellen R. Wald, Ph.D. is a historian and scholar of the energy industry. She writes and consults on the intersection of geopolitics and energy.
34 Comments on "Which Way Is Oil Going?"
Apneaman on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 3:35 pm
Which Way Is Oil Going?
It’s going South
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mGZ8NuIRU5Y
Plantagenet on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 3:58 pm
We’re still in an oil glut. There is enough oversupply in the market that Oil prices are headed back down again.
Cheers!
Boat on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 5:30 pm
Nigeria agreed to resume payments to rebels they had cut off in February. 700,000 -1.4 mbpd may come back to the market? Libya another 300,000-1.1 mbpd over a year? This glut was assumed to be 2 mbpd then over 1.5 years or so dropped to 300,000.
Demand for a year is around 1.3 so math says a glut to 2018 is possible.
yoshua on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 7:23 pm
Oil is going to hell ?
makati1 on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 7:35 pm
In many old cartoons, one character asks another character: “Which way?” and the other character points both directions.
Oil’s future is the same way. Both ways. Until it it finally breaks the oil companies backs and the Age of Petroleum ends. The billions of barrels of petroleum that are left will remain in the ground and humanity’s future will change radically.
When? This year? Next? Who knows, but soon. The oily black swans are getting tired from the aerial acrobatics (price changes) of recent years as one by one, they fall from the sky due to lack of energy (profit).
shortonoil on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 7:42 pm
“Why were we tricked into thinking the worst of the oil glut was over?”
Because there is only so much oil, like string bikinis, and cheap Chinese wall ornaments, that the economy can absorb. We reached that level with oil.
What happens now is the question that we have attempted to answer.
http://www.thehillsgroup.org/
Roger on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 8:01 pm
Actually, the present correction is just that, a correction in the up trend. The USDX (so called “dollar”) rally on Brexit provided sufficient cover for the boyz on Wall St. to take oil down. However, that is done…USDX is cratering. When USDX breaks 94 (soon) the uptrend will resume.
Regarding, the author’s contention that “shale companies are well financed”, all I can say is JAKNPhD (just another know nothing PhD). She is clueless to the present state of energy finance.
Boat on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 8:26 pm
short,
You might have been tricked but I follow oil and its news. Demand is healthy and is even higher than first of the year estimates. The fundamentals for higher oil and/or lower production are always there. One has to read to know what’s possible.
Geopolitics has played a much bigger role in demand and pricing than depletion.
bahamased on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 9:06 pm
We have a glut of oil, a fact.
Why do we have a glut? because we can’t sell all the oil we are pumping out of the ground.
Therefore we will keep lowering the price until we can sell all the oil we are pumping.
Or we go bankrupt
Northwest Resident on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 9:51 pm
Boat: “Demand is healthy”
Worries Rise Over Global Trade Slump – WSJ
“A sharp drop in global trade growth this year…”
http://www.wsj.com/articles/worries-rise-over-global-trade-slump-1442251590
Chinese manufacturing fall adds to evidence of sharp global downturn
“Factory output contracted in China and the UK during February while growth slowed in France, Germany, Italy and the US to indicate that businesses and consumers remain wary of committing themselves to large orders while the direction of global trade remains uncertain.”
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/mar/01/chinese-manufacturing-decline-sharp-global-downturn-factory-output-china-uk
But “demand is healthy”, according to Boat. Go figure.
GregT on Tue, 2nd Aug 2016 11:01 pm
“But “demand is healthy”, according to Boat. Go figure.”
Once an idiot, always an idiot. You can’t fix stupid.
shortonoil on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 8:34 am
“Actually, the present correction is just that, a correction in the up trend. The USDX (so called “dollar”) rally on Brexit provided sufficient cover for the boyz on Wall St. to take oil down. “
The price has been falling for 2 and a half years, and inventories have been growing for three. The “present correction” is present only if you are a Mayfly with a one day life expediency. The industry is going broke all over the world at warp speed. That is the only “correction” that is taking place at “present”.
diemos on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 11:00 am
Which Way Is Oil Going?
Up out of the ground and into the atmosphere.
marmico on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 11:46 am
The industry is going broke all over the world at warp speed.
What a crock of shit. The Persian Gulf and Russia, combined at ~35 mb/d production is profitable @ $40/b.
US frackers are fucked. So what. It is 5% of daily ~80 mb/d of global production.
The EROI of gasoline in my tank is at a record high in 2016.
Davy on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 12:37 pm
Marmi, I find that statement deceptive considering both Russia and Saudi are in a recessionary environment becuase of low oil prices. You are just not looking at the bigger picture and it is the bigger picture that matters. Looking at operating profit without considering other requirements of their oil extraction activities is narrow minded.
marmico on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 1:10 pm
You fall for the usual bull shit Davy “indigestible word salad” Greenacres.
Saudi Aramco is profitable at $10 a barrel. The House of Saud was profligate while running up a $750 billion sovereign wealth fund between 2002 and 2014. They “extracted” a lot of money from oil consumers in that period and now they are drawing it down to support their continued “less” profligacy.
Apneaman on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 1:23 pm
marmi, can you tells us all again how today’s Joe Six pack has it sooooo much better than yesteryears Joe sixpack, cause of smartphones N stuff. I like that story.
Homeownership Rate in the U.S. Drops to Lowest Since 1965
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-07-28/homeownership-rate-in-the-u-s-tumbles-to-the-lowest-since-1965
marmico on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 1:43 pm
https://www.aei.org/publication/1991-radio-shack-ad-13-electronic-products-for-5k-and-290-hrs-work-can-now-be-replaced-with-a-200-iphone-10-hrs/
PracticalMaina on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 1:45 pm
The old encyclopedia does not contribute to cancer when you hold it to your head though.
tagio on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 2:17 pm
Marm said:
” (citing short)’The industry is going broke all over the world at warp speed.’
What a crock of shit. The Persian Gulf and Russia, combined at ~35 mb/d production is profitable @ $40/b.”
$40/b might be “profitable” in terms of getting the stuff out of the ground and to market, but it sure as hell isn’t enough to support Saudia Arabian government and society, which is why KSA is liquidating financial reserves hand over fist and looking to IPO an interest in their reserves to suckers who think the low price is some kind of cyclial phenom that is going to reverse. KSA’s fiscal breakeven (to acheive a balanced budget) for 2015 was estimated to be about $100/b.
If you narrow your focus enough and exclude enough costs, it’s amazing what things are “profitable.” E.g., some people argue that nuclear power plants can be “competititive” esp. if you just ignore the decommissioning costs and assume the Federal or State governments will kindly pay for disposal of the waste because, after all, all those people living within a 50-100 mile radius are effectively hostages. See, e.g., the role that bank depositors play as the hostages guaranteeing that the big banks will be bailed out. Amazingly, even though KSA oil operations are “profitable,” KSA is going to hell.
Apneaman on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 2:23 pm
marmi, your link wants me to complete a security check to access http://www.aei.org? Get real for fucks sakes. What’s next – secret decoder rings?
marmico on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 2:34 pm
Okay. Source document. Equivalency.
Some white bread kid in Mountain View, California spent 290 hours working at MickeyDees to buy the Radio Shack electronic package in 1991, while some black bread kid in Baltimore, Maryland spent 20 seconds stealing an IPhone in 2016.
http://www.trendingbuffalo.com/life/uncle-steves-buffalo/everything-from-1991-radio-shack-ad-now/
PracticalMaina on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 2:59 pm
You can eat semi-conductors right, drink them? and sleep inside them? Do they cure cancer?
Some douche bag with an online name Marmico took 365 days a year to be as fucktarded as he could be.
How long did it take slaves to source the material for the iphone, would be the most important question IMHO.
Apneaman on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 3:29 pm
marmi, I don’t give a fuck fantasy boy. Your beloved ideology is a big phony stinking piece of shit. There is no free market or any of that other bulshit you have devoted your life to. The economy is micromanaged to a level that would embarrass the Soviets. Fake. Dosen’t even come close to resembling what it was in my youth, yet all you devotees still use the same language as if it does. No market. Micro managed Big gov economy hanging on for dear life.
makati1 on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 6:04 pm
Agree with you about cell phones and their negative consequences. I rarely have to use mine, thank goodness. I would never uses electronics instead of real books. Like pictures stored on those little chips, someday, they will vanish forever.
I am building a very extensive reference and leisure library of paper books here, mostly used, for when the internet is dead. Including a set of English teaching school books for other generations to learn English so they can access them. Schools are not forever either.
Boat on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 7:31 pm
OPEC’s 13 member countries saw oil export revenues slump to their lowest level in a decade last year.
Crude revenues fell nearly 46% to $518 billion in 2015, according to OPEC’s annual bulletin published Wednesday.
http://money.cnn.com/2016/06/23/news/economy/opec-export-revenues-10-year-low-deficit/
If I am a country with few recources I would think any revenues from FF would be great. I think Opec will keep drilling to get even more revenue.
Roger on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 10:46 pm
Shortonoil,
“The price has been falling for 2 and a half years, and inventories have been growing for three. The “present correction” is present only if you are a Mayfly with a one day life expediency. The industry is going broke all over the world at warp speed. That is the only “correction” that is taking place at “present”.”
Grab a clue — oil bottomed in February…even the boyz on Wall Street concede that. I’d link to a price chart, but you already know how it looks. Which begs the question — why are you denying the obvious? I could venture a guess, but won’t.
Roger on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 11:13 pm
Boat,
“If I am a country with few recources I would think any revenues from FF would be great. I think Opec will keep drilling to get even more revenue.”
Actually, OPEC could double their revenue by simply cutting production by 10 percent. They know this…
What’s happening, I suspect, is more “geo-political / strategic” in nature. I don’t claim to understand it…and don’t buy the simplistic CNBC explanations/propaganda.
Northwest Resident on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 11:23 pm
Roger, I think I detect a fallacy in your logic.
First, you say that oil (price) bottomed in February, which it did. But is your implication that it is all up for the price of oil from here? In other words, are you saying that the bottom in February is “the” bottom, that we won’t be seeing that again? Because if you are, then you’re making a very bold prediction.
Isn’t it true that on a longer timeline, say since around 2014 up to now, the long term trend line for price oil is most definitely “down”?
Do you believe what the boyz on Wall Street say, or pretend to be conceding? If not, why use what those boyz are supposedly saying as a supporting argument?
Isn’t it true that without massive central bank “stimulus” (aka: debt) the price of oil and indeed almost all commodities and assets would be in free fall? Surely you recognize that the only thing propping up your price of oil and the “market” is constant, massive debt issuance?
And isn’t it also true that on a global basis, while oil production has been “up” (though barely so) over past years, that production has only been made possible by ZIRP and debt, and that in fact the oil industry as a whole is totally flat-out losing its ass right now? Are would you argue that no, the oil industry is doing just fine — perhaps because the price of oil bottomed in February and all is well now?
And finally, are you saying that the increase barrel count (production) is providing the world with more net energy than ever before? Because if that is your point, then it must be safe to assume that you’re totally discounting the dramatically increased energy and effort (work) required to produce oil these days given the advanced depletion state that the oil industry finds itself in.
I could venture a guess as to who needs to grab a clue, but won’t.
makati1 on Wed, 3rd Aug 2016 11:34 pm
Rodger:
“Actually, OPEC could double their revenue by simply cutting production by 10 percent. They know this…”
I doubt it would work. Too many other suppliers willing to undercut their price for market share. That tactic only works when there is a demand for more than is prouced, and that time is over for good.
The world is producing too much oil and a million bbls/day cut by OPEC would only open the market for the non OPEC producers.
Besides, all of the OPEC producers are fighting to keep their market share. Which on would be the first to cut? Answer: None!
Boat on Thu, 4th Aug 2016 10:39 am
Roger,
” oil bottomed in February…even the boyz on Wall Street concede that”
If Libya and Nigeria happen to produce more oil than high cost producers drop production, a new lower bottom could happen. As usual, oil prices are at the mercy of geopolitical events.
Boat on Thu, 4th Aug 2016 10:45 am
Roger,
“Actually, OPEC could double their revenue by simply cutting production by 10 percent. They know this…”
They also know frackers would jump in and replace that cut in production.
GregT on Thu, 4th Aug 2016 1:58 pm
The Boat non-sensical quote of the day:
“They also know frackers would jump in and replace that cut in production.”
I’m willing to bet that he doesn’t have the foggiest clue as to why.
Northwest Resident on Thu, 4th Aug 2016 7:57 pm
“They also know frackers would jump in and replace that cut in production.”
Not without a trillion$ or two in additional debt complimented by a multi-billion$ propaganda campaign to sucker the muppets in (again), they wouldn’t.