We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

When the residents of Tulsa, Oklahoma buried a car in 1957 as part of an enormous time capsule, they included containers of gasoline. The good people of Tulsa reasoned that the folks of 2007 might not have any gas left to fill up the Plymouth Belvedere that they were interring for a fifty year journey into the future. Boy were they ever wrong.

Throughout the 20th century we became tremendously dependent on oil. At the risk of stating the obvious, the world would look completely different today without it. But time and again, very smart people have predicted that we’d eventually run out of oil. Time and again those predictions were proven incorrect.

With gas prices currently plunging, it’s difficult to see any real end to the fossil fuel-based economy we’ve built. American consumption of oil is showing signs of plateauing and our oil imports have fallen to their lowest level since 1987. But historically that’s meant that people become complacent and start doing dumb shit like buying Hummers and doing less to conserve energy. Just look at this article from Bloomberg Businessweek yesterday called “With $2 Gas, The Toyota Prius is For Drivers Who Stink At Math.”123

The idea of peak oil has popped up repeatedly throughout the 20th and 21st centuries. But as I sit typing these words, the gas station nearby is selling a gallon of gas for under $3 — bargain basement prices for Los Angeles. It’s a wonderful boost for cash-strapped consumers, but I’m reminded that I might not see peak oil within my lifetime.

So join me as we revisit the oil predictions of yesteryear; times when humans were convinced that we were almost out of oil. Only to be proven wrong for any number of reasons — including the discovery of new sources, conservation efforts to stem consumption, and the development of new technologies to get that black gold out of the ground.

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1909: 25 or 30 years longer

“Petroleum has been used for less than 50 years, and it is estimated that the supply will last about 25 or 30 years longer. If production is curtailed and waste stopped it may last till the end of the century. The most important effects of its disappearance will be in the lack of illuminants. Animal and vegetable oils will not begin to supply its place. This being the case, the reckless exploitation of oil fields and the consumption of oil for fuel should be checked.”

— July 19, 1909 Titusville Herald (Titusville, PA)

Image: Oil field in Beaumont, Texas circa 1901 via AP

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a Century

1919: Two to five years until maximum production

“In meeting the world’s needs, however, the oil from the United States will continue to occupy a less and less dominant position, because within the next two to five years the oil fields of this country will reach their maximum production and from that on we will face an ever increasing decline.”

— October 23, 1919 Oil and Gas News

Image: Burkburnett, Texas in 1919 via Library of Congress

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1937: Gone in 15 years

Capt. H. A. Stuart, director of the naval petroleum reserves, told the Senate Naval Affairs Committee today the oil supply of this country will last only about 15 years.

“We have been making estimates for the last 15 years,’ Stuart said. ‘We always underestimate because of the possibility of discovering new oil fields. The best information is that the present supply will last only 15 years. That is a conservative estimate.'”

— March 9, 1937 Brooklyn Daily Eagle

Image: Oil field in Los Angeles circa 1935 via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1943: Peak oil has been reached

“There is a growing opinion that the United States has reached its peak oil production, the Oil and Gas Journal pointed out in its current issue. Since 1938, discoveries of new oil have not equaled withdrawals, in any single year, although there is a very good chance that 1943 will see enough new Ellenburger oil in West Texas to provide an excess.”

— June 7, 1943 Bradford Evening Star (Bradford, PA)

Image: Oil truck in New Orleans in 1943 via Library of Congress

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1945: Just thirteen years left

“Faced with the threat that our nation’s petroleum reserves may last only thirteen years, geologists are striving to tap the almost limitless supply of oil located beneath the seas off our coastline. The first attempt to get oil from the depths of the Atlantic Ocean was begun this month near Cape Hatteras, North Carolina, and Secretary of the Interior Harold L. Ickes revealed that the scientists are making progress in their efforts to reach the underwater oil.”

— December 10, 1945 Times Recorder (Zanesville, Ohio)

Image: Oil-burning train in London circa 1946 via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1956: Ten to fifteen years until peak oil

“M. King Hubbert of the Shell Development Co. predicted [one year ago] that peak oil production would be reached in the next 10 to 15 years and after that would gradually decline.”

— March 9, 1957 Corpus Christi Times (Corpus Christi, TX)

Gas station attendant wearing rollerskates in 1958 via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1966: Gone in ten years

“A geologist stuck a figurative dipstick into the United States’ oil supplies Tuesday and estimated that the country may be dry in 10 years.”

— August 3, 1966 Brandon Sun (Brandon, Manitoba)

Image: North Sea drilling rig circa 1965 via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand4

1972: U.S. oil depleted in twenty years

“At any rate, U.S. oil supplies will last only 20 years. Foreign supplies will last 40 or 50 years, but are increasingly dependent upon world politics.”

— May 1972 Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists

Image: Four people on horses in Amsterdam in 1973 during a day when cars are banned due to the oil crisis via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1977: Oil will peak by the early 90s

“As a nation, Americans have been reluctant to accept the prospect of physical shortages. We must recognize that world oil production will likely peak in the early 1990’s, and from that point on will be on a declining curve. By the early part of the 21st century, we must face the prospect of running out of oil and natural gas.”

— 1977 US Department of Energy Organization Act

Image: French fireman clean up an oil spill in 1978 via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1980: In the year 2000

“Stressing the need for conservation, [physicist Dr. Hans] Bethe said the world will reach its peak oil production before the year 2000. Production of oil worldwide will then drop to zero over about 20 years, he said. Rigorous conservation could stretch the world’s oil supply to the year 2050, he said.

— October 17, 1980 Syracuse Post Standard (Syracuse, NY)

Image: Oil rig workers in England in 1980 via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

1996: Peak oil likely by 2020

“Unfortunately, oil production will likely peak by 2020 and start declining. Without a change, developing countries will ultimately be left in the dark, and developed countries will struggle to keep the lights on. Conflict is inevitable. My guess is that this won’t become a big issue unless there is a thalidomide event. We will have to see in the rear-view mirror that we are past the peak in worldwide oil production.”

— Richard Smalley, Nobel Laureate in Chemistry, 1996

Image: Oil rig platform in 1998 via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

2002: Global peak by the year 2010

“Global supplies of crude oil will peak as early as 2010 and then start to decline, ushering in an era of soaring energy prices and economic upheaval — or so said an international group of petroleum specialists meeting Friday.”

— May 25, 2002 Index Journal (Greenwood, SC)

Image: Oil platforms off the coast of Santa Barbara in 2001 via Getty

We've Been Incorrectly Predicting Peak Oil For Over a CenturyExpand

2007: Sometime between now and 2040

Most studies estimate that oil production will peak sometime between now and 2040. This range of estimates is wide because the timing of the peak depends on multiple, uncertain factors that will help determine how quickly the oil remaining in the ground is used, including the amount of oil still in the ground; how much of that oil can ultimately be produced given technological, cost, and environmental challenges as well as potentially unfavorable political and investment conditions in some countries where oil is located; and future global demand for oil.

— February 2007 GAO Report

Image: Gas flare near an abandoned building in North Dakota in 2013 via Getty

If anything should become clear by reading these predictions it’s that we can’t wait for oil to disappear before we wean ourselves from it. We have some significant momentum, but there’s a very real danger of slipping back into oil’s warm, wet embrace. It’s comfortable, it’s familiar, and it’s irreparably harming our chances at long-term existence on this planet.5

The idea of peak oil has arguably contributed to climate change more than any other meme of the 20th century. Rather than making the case for alternative energy sources, too many people believed that it would be a problem that eventually sorted itself out. Of course, it didn’t.

So whatever happened to that 1957 Belvedere? When they dug it up it was little more than a rusted hunk of metal.

Paleofuture