Page added on June 12, 2012
Yes, everything you know about economics is wrong. Dead wrong. Everything. The conclusions of economists are based on a fiction that distorts everything else. As a result economics is as real as one of the summer blockbusters like “Battleship,” “The Avenger” or “Prometheus.”
The difference is that the economic profession is a genuine threat, not entertainment. Economics dogma is on track to destroy the world with a misleading ideology.
Why? Because all economics is based on the absurd Myth of Perpetual Growth. Yes, all theories and business plans based on growth are mythological.
Economists are master illusionists who rely on a set of fictions, fantasies and forecasts that emanate from a core magical mantra of Perpetual Growth that goes untested year after year.
And yet it’s used to manipulate the public into a set of policies and decisions that are leading the American and the world economy down a path of unsustainable globalization and GDP growth assumptions that will self-destruct the planet.
Yes, economists are addicted to this ideology. Trapped deep in their denial, can’t see the problem, or admit it, or if they do, they are unable to stop themselves, see past their own myopic world view. They’re mercenaries working for capitalists who pay their salaries, and expect them to support the capitalist’s bizarre Myth of Perpetual Growth.
Worse, the public also bought into the myth. Yes, you believe everything you learned in college about economic theories, all the textbooks, everything you read in the daily press, the government reports, all those Wall Street analysts’ predictions relying on studies prepared by economists with credentials.
But everything you think you know about economics … is wrong. Dead wrong. And until economics acknowledge this, the discipline is on a self-destruct path.
Why? The science of economics is not science. Yes, it looks scientific with all the fancy math algorithms and computer models that economists use, but all that’s just window dressing to make the economist look scientific and rational.
They’re not. Their conclusions are pre-ordained, fabricated, based on their biases, personal ideologies and whatever their employer wants to prove to manipulate consumers, voters or investors to buy what they’re selling.
Don’t believe me? Go look at USA Today’s quarterly surveys of 50 economists projections of GDP growth. Invariably off by a large margin. And Barron’s Big Money poll? In past reviews we’ve seen a wide gap in forecasts by the bulls and bears.
Bottom line: Whether it’s Roubini or Roach, Kudlow or Krugman, you can’t trust the predictions of any economist. Ever. Best warning: That famous BusinessWeek editorial several years ago headlined: “What Do You Call an Economist with a Prediction? Wrong.”
Unfortunately, we live in a world of capitalists who thrive on the great Myth of Perpetual Growth, endless growth, ad infinitum, forever, till the end of time.
But driving the economists’ growth myth is population growth. It’s the independent variable in their equation. Population growth drives all other derivative projections, forecasts and predictions. All GDP growth, income growth, wealth growth, production growth, everything. These unscientific growth assumptions fit into the overall left-brain, logical, mind-set of western leaders, all the corporate CEOs, Wall Street bankers and government leaders who run America and the world.
But just because a large group collectively believes in something doesn’t make it true. Perpetual growth is still a myth no matter how many economists, CEOs, bankers and politicians believe it. It’s still an illusion trapped in the brains of all these irrational, biased and uncritical folks.
Capitalism itself is at a crossroads. Growth is capitalism’s sacred cow but it’s “grow or die” theory doesn’t work anymore. With us since 1776, it’s being challenged by a “new god of reality” that’s flashing warnings of an emerging new reality from critics, contrarians and eco-economists. This war is pitting old and new economists:
Grow OR Die. Traditional economists (pro-capitalism): We’re told we need 3% GDP growth to support the next batch of 100 million Americans. We believe it on faith. Drill Baby Drill. Buy stuff. Get new jobs to fuel growth. We’re out of control. Exploding growth fuels demands as the rest of the world adds 2.9 billion new humans, all chasing their “American dream.”
Grow AND Die. New eco-economists (environmentalists): They see Big Oil’s destruction of our coastal economies, the rape of West Virginia’s coal mountains, the unintended consequences of uncontrolled carbon emissions and they ask: “When will economists, politicians and corporate leaders stop pretending Earth’s resources are infinitely renewable?”
Yes, our world is at a crossroads, facing a dilemma, confronting the ultimate no-win scenario, because the “Myth of Perpetual Growth” is essential to support the global population explosion. But all this “Growth” is also killing our world, wasting our planet’s non-renewable natural resources. “Eternal Growth” is suicidal, will eventually destroy Earth. We’re damned if we grow. Damned if we don’t.
But will economists change as long as they’re mercenaries in the employ of Perpetual Growth Capitalists? No. It will take a new mind-set. The difference between the mind-set of traditional economists and the new eco-economists is simple: Traditional economists think short-term, react short-term, pursue short-term goals. New eco-economists think long-term.
Initially this may seem overly simplistic, but fits perfectly. Here’s why:
Old traditional economists — short-term thinkers: Traditional economists are employees and consultants for organizations with short-term views — banks, big corporations, institutional investors, think-tanks, government. They all think in lock-step, driven by daily returns, quarterly earnings, annual bonuses. Short business and election cycles are more important than what happens a decade in the future. Their brains are convinced: If we can’t survive the short, long-term is irrelevant.
Environmental economists — long-term thinkers: New eco-economists see, think and plan for the long-term. They know traditional economists’ and capitalists’ thinking is setting America up for more and bigger catastrophes than the Gulf oil spill and the last meltdown. The “Avatar” film is a perfect metaphor: Soon capitalism will exhaust Earth’s resources forcing us to invade distant planets searching for new energy resources.
Actually something more immediate will force change much sooner. You are not going to like it: United Nations and Pentagon studies predict population growth (the main driver of all economic growth) will create unsustainable natural-resources demands as early as 2020 with global population exploding from seven to 10 billion by 2050. So expect Depression Era austerity, unemployment and a new no-growth economy.
Will we change? In time? Plan ahead? No, we won’t wake up without a collapse. We know the Myth of Perpetual Growth is pure fiction. But we also know our leaders, capitalists, economists and politicians all live in a collective conscience that must believe in this bizarre myth in order to justify everything they believe about the future, about progress, about income and wealth increasing, about a better life.
So we will all hang on … until a catastrophe shocks our world, forces us to wake up and let go, newly aware of the absurdity of the Myth of Perpetual Growth on a planet of finite resources. And it will happen sooner than you think.
12 Comments on "Myth of Perpetual Growth is killing America"
BillT on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 2:08 pm
Will you be the first to sell you car and buy a bicycle? ^_^ How about pulling the plug on your A/C? Giving up your Starbucks fix? McDonalds? Walmart? Trips to the beach, casino, mountains? Imported foods. Imports of all kinds? Plastics?
No? You will, one way or the other.
Bernz223 on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 2:24 pm
Shut your ass up BillT isn’t it time to go to the euthenasia center yet for you? After all your 67 pretty close if not already at the useless eater stage.
cottager on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 2:52 pm
to Bernz223
The truth that he’s telling is not that you like, isn’t it? So you’re offending, oh, how old/young you are, means I don’t like what are you telling, means I don’t have arguments. This is sad 🙁
Rick on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 3:37 pm
@ Bernz223
Sorry you dislike what BillT is saying. Anger is the first stage, when hearing the truth.
Newfie on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 4:31 pm
The Prophet of Peak Oil said it decades ago:
“We have evolved a culture so heavily dependent upon the continuance of exponential growth for its stability that it is incapable of reckoning with problems of non-growth … it behooves us … to begin a serious examination of the … cultural adjustments necessary … before unmanageable crises arise…” – M. King Hubbert
Kenz300 on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 4:36 pm
Quote — ” United Nations and Pentagon studies predict population growth (the main driver of all economic growth) will create unsustainable natural-resources demands as early as 2020 with global population exploding from seven to 10 billion by 2050. So expect Depression Era austerity, unemployment and a new no-growth economy.”
————————
Endless population growth is the source of the problem.
Hubbertsfreak on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 5:24 pm
Economics is very dangerous. Economists are trained to ignore most things–Externalities–are explained away with words like “ceteris paribus.” I remember the first example I learned in college was that Lobster fisherman should base quotas on the price of Lobster rather than stock of lobtster in the sea or rate of replenishment. Yes, economists may be the most dangerous people on earth.
SOS on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 6:17 pm
What is growth? Did the first buggy whip company grow? Did the newspaper business grow? How about livery stables, did they grow? Did Detroit grow? What about the welfare culture, did it grow? How about the earths population, is it growing? Will it ever shrink?
Growth is just change. There are more than enough resources on the earth to supply that change perpetually through the use and resoration cycle. Resources are perpetual and the ones we consider valuable are always changing over time.
Norm on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 6:35 pm
Something I like about Peak Oil website, is articles & posters are diplomatic and refrain from personal attacks. As such, it would be much better, if BillT did not get an insulting post from another.
As to this article, it looks correct enough. ‘Growth’ is a myth because you would need a larger planet to keep going. Peak Everything is already taking place.
Eventually the only jobs available is digging thru those garbage landfills with a handshovel. Try to find some resources with a pair of tweezers. People should have been doing sustainable things all these years, but they refuse to do so.
The current recession that is occurring, would not occur at all if the society was more sustainable. People say they cant afford to build a house. Why? Cause the supplies are expensive, like the copper wire. Why is the copper wire expensive? Cause nobody will recycle anything, they keep throwing out #12 extension cords in their daily trash.
Wasteful people tossing away all the steel copper and aluminum, are their own problem, and in their authentic ignorance, they blame it on somebody else like the incumbent president.
Siddhartha on Tue, 12th Jun 2012 7:47 pm
“The Avengers” not “The Avenger” sheesh, get an editor already.
DMyers on Wed, 13th Jun 2012 1:37 am
Sad to say, the economists are actually correct about the nature of the problem. Economists posit that humans are driven by self interest.
And so, the following occurs. The moderation necessary to sustainability is thwarted by self-interest. Suppose I were motivated by a cause to preserve resources for my children and grandchildren. I halve my gasoline consumption in order to do my part and to demand sacrifice of myself.
As I pull away from the pump, a giant SUV pulls up and its obese, stereo blasting, energy drink drinking, Dancing with the Stars watching, widest screen TV on the block owning slob tops his tank without the least thought about his own impact on the world of everyone else.
I say to myself, “that’s it for me. That embecile just took the gas I tried to save.”
And so there is no incentive for me to act on the interest of the whole, as others destroy the contribution I made, receive the benefit of my effort, and in the end negate the positive effect I attempted to cause.
If you read the right economists, that is what they are saying. Sure perpetual growth is impossible and self-defeating, but he who will lower his standards and suffer a lesser lifestyle, lead the way on the downward slope, let him cast the first stone. It is our nature that we will grow until we hit the wall.
BillT on Wed, 13th Jun 2012 4:09 am
Actually, DM, you have been brainwashed from day one to consume. It is not a natural desire. Hunter gatherers knew that if they consumed too much they had to move to a new area and the hazards that implied. Many countries do NOT over consume. It is NOT in your genes. It is in your mind. You get that reinforced with every commercial, movie, video, or article you absorb daily.