Register

Peak Oil is You


Donate Bitcoins ;-) or Paypal :-)


Page added on September 15, 2010

Bookmark and Share

Peak Coal Could Strike by 2011 – Reuters

Production

A recent study predicts existing coalmines around the world will reach peak production as early as next year, with peak production levels cut in half by the turn of the century.

This runs counter to current estimates of global coal reserves, which researchers from the University of Texas in Austin and the University of California at Berkeley call overblown and and sometimes based on dated or unreliable information.

Tadeusz W. Patzek and and Gregory D. Croft, authors of the recent study published in the August issue of Energy, estimate coal production rates will decline after 2011, reaching 1990 levels by 2037.  The pair believe future mines won’t be able to reverse the trend.

In a National Geographic article published last week, Patzek contends that current estimates of coal don’t reflect the reality that hard-to-get, lower quality coal reserves may never be harvested because it is not economically or environmentally feasible. For example, proven coal reserves in Illinois are high, but production has dwindled over the last two decades, in part because the coal has a high sulfur content. Federal regulations that address acid rain make lower-sulfur coal from Wyoming and Montana more attractive.

This raised questions about the credibility of some coal reserve estimates, Patzek told National Geographic.

“The only estimate that’s credible is what actually comes out of the mines, and how you project that into the future,” he said.

The World Coal Institute in London estimates coal use will climb 60 percent over the next two decades, with reserves available for the next 119 years, National Geographic reported. The National Academy of Sciences predicts coal can meet the nation’s needs for 100 years at current rates of consumption. Coal supplies 40 percent of the world’s electricity; some estimate it is responsible for about 20 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions.

The theory underpinning the report is based on the argument that coal production follows a bell-curve over time, similar to the method developed by Marion King Hubbert, who predicted that oil production in the U.S. would peak in the early 1970s. Coal production in the U.K. followed this pattern.

Reuters



One Comment on "Peak Coal Could Strike by 2011 – Reuters"

  1. Edpeak on Thu, 16th Sep 2010 6:09 am 

    Apples and oranges, yet again! As usual, we get lines like:

    “he World Coal Institute in London estimates coal use will climb 60 percent over the next two decades, with reserves available for the next 119 years”

    but that doesn’t tell us when they think it will PEAK. Don’t compare apples and oranges! Presumably they think peak is at least 20 years away, given the prediction of rising, but how many years away? 20? 21? 22? they don’t say, and refuse to say, as far as one can tell. Can’t take seriously if either the reporter is sloppy or the source, or both.

    Even worse:

    “The National Academy of Sciences predicts coal can meet the nation’s needs for 100 years at current rates of consumption.”

    What about non-constant consumption levels? Then less than 100 year, so a second switch between what we want to know and other numbers that don’t answer the real questions, but even “how long will it last with increasing production?” is still the wrong question if you want to compare predictions apples-to-apples: When does NAS predict PEAK? The article won’t say.

    No wonder people are dumbed-down when reporters keep comparing one person’s DATE OF PEAK with another groups DATE OF RUNNING OUT.

    Geez

    Par for the course though…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *